14 thoughts on “CC0 (+BY)

  1. Pingback: What We're Reading: December 5, 2013

  2. Eric Hellman

    I am one of those who “use, reuse, and commingle data”; I’ve been doing it for quite a while. I very well “know the complex issues that arise with even simple additional requirements such as this”.

    But I’ve seen for myself that lack of provenance is the black death of metadata. The problems with CC BY for data are real, but they’re not caused by legal or moral shortcomings, they’re caused by flimsy and cumbersome attribution technology. I think we’ll see the emergence over the next few years the sort of convenient, strong attribution/provenance technology for data that we are starting to see effectively deployed by GitHub for code.

    So think of your metadata as kittens.
    Today our licensing options are:
    CC0: “Free kittens. We don’t care if you let them die.”
    CC BY: “Free kittens. You’d better take care of them.”
    CC0 (+BY): “Free kittens. We’d be sad if you let them die”

  3. Pingback: The British Library to Crowdsource a Million+ Images | Enfilade

  4. Pingback: British Library stellt Bilder ins Netz | The LastBlog

  5. Pingback: British Library Adds 1m Free Images to Flickr

  6. Pingback: Open access and going digital in 2013 | The Shakespeare blog

  7. Pingback: Copyleft, IP Rights, and Digital Humanities Dissertations | Literature Geek by Amanda Visconti (@Literature_Geek)

  8. Pingback: Copyleft, IP Rights, and Digital Humanities Dissertations | Literature Geek

  9. Pingback: Building an archaeological project repository II: Where are the research data repositories? | Open Knowledge Foundation Blog

  10. Pingback: Digital scholarship blog | 403 Forbidden

  11. Pingback: OpenGLAM progress and potential in Aotearoa New Zealand | OpenGLAM

  12. Pingback: The Disease Ontology license converted to CC0 | The Su Lab

  13. Egon Willighagen

    Eric, I think your analogy is close, but I feel that it is more like:

    CC BY: “Free kittens. We don’t care if you let them die, but please cite our shop where you bought them.”

    In other news, at some point in time I saw an add-on document, independent from the license, that covers the BY part. As a scholar, I don’t care, because it is a faux-pas to not cite the origin. However, even academics seem to require reminder of that, and then such a BY clause is useful. Sadly, I can no longer find the text of that add-on :(

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *